Are you taking an unsustainable amount from your pension?

November 04, 2020

If you’re choosing to access your pension flexibly, one of the risks is that you could take too much from your pension too soon. Your pension is likely needed to provide an income for several decades and evidence suggests that many retirees could find their pensions will run out during their lifetime.

Since 2015, retirees have been able to access their pension flexibly through drawdown. This means you withdraw an income when it suits you, with the rest usually remaining invested. It’s proved popular and allows you to create an income that suits your retirement lifestyle. However, it also means you need to consider things like what a sustainable income is.

Why the 4% rule may no longer be suitable

In the past, a common rule of thumb was that you should take no more than 4% of your pension each year to ensure that it lasts throughout retirement. However, sticking to this rule today could mean you’re more likely to run out of money. Many factors play a role in why this ‘rule’ may no longer apply, including the following three examples.

  1. Market conditions have changed. Over the last decade, interest rates have been low, falling even further in response to the economic challenges of Covid-19 this year. Coupled with market volatility, it means your pension investments may no longer be delivering the performance previously expected. As a result, a lower ‘rule’ of 3% or even less is more likely to be sustainable given current market conditions.
  2. People are spending more time in retirement. While the age we can access our pension and State Pension is gradually rising, longevity has increased at a faster pace. Those retiring today are likely to enjoy a longer retirement than previous generations. Pension savings now need to stretch further to ensure long-term financial security.
  3. Retirement spending often isn’t linear. How we retire and our income throughout retirement is changing too. In the past, retirees gave up work on a set date and income needs would remain consistent throughout retirement. Now, you may decide that a phased retirement is for you, go back to work in some way later in life or have plans that mean income needs fluctuate. This is good news for creating a lifestyle that suits you, but it makes it far more difficult to set out a ‘rule’ that applies to the majority of retirees.

42% of pensions accessed at ‘unsustainable’ levels

It’s difficult to state when pension withdrawals would be unsustainable without knowing the individual circumstances of each person. However, the latest data on retirement income from the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), covering 2019/20, suggests more than four in ten people could face financial challenges in their later years.

Some 42% are taking more than 8% from their pension each year, an increase of 40% from the previous period. Withdrawals at this level lead to a high risk that pension savings will run out during your lifetime.

The figures show high withdrawal levels are more likely to occur when accessing smaller pension pots. Some 67% of those using an 8% withdrawal rate had a pension worth between £10,000 and £99,000. This compares to 24% with a pension worth more than £100,000. Those with pensions worth more than £250,000 tended to be more cautious and take smaller withdrawals.

Of course, the figures alone fail to show the full picture. Those taking larger levels from smaller pensions may also hold several other pensions and are using a strategy to use each pot in turn. However, the figures do indicate that many retirees could be at risk of running out of money sooner than expected.

The importance of understanding your retirement and income

Decisions made in early retirement can have a long-lasting impact. Taking too much from your pension in the early years of retirement can mean investment returns fall significantly and fail to provide an adequate income later in life, for instance.

As you approach retirement, assessing the assets you have to create an income, including pensions, and your plans are crucial. While ‘rules’ can give you a general idea, taking the time to understand your desired lifestyle and assets can mean you’re in a position to create a plan that works for you. What works for one person can be very different from another, even if their circumstances appear similar on the surface.

Working with a financial planner allows you to get the most out of your retirement, safe in the knowledge that your latter years have been considered.

Talk to us to understand your pension and retirement income

At the point of retirement, you need to make many decisions, including how and when you’ll access your pension. Longevity and sustainable withdrawals are just one aspect you need to consider. If you’re already retired or nearing retirement, we’re here to help you. We’ll work with you to understand your retirement goals and how your pension and other assets can be used to achieve them with your whole retirement in mind. Please contact us to arrange a meeting.

Please note: This blog is for general information only and does not constitute advice. The information is aimed at retail clients only.

A pension is a long-term investment. The fund value may fluctuate and can go down, which would have an impact on the level of pension benefits available. Your pension income could also be affected by the interest rates at the time you take your benefits. The tax implications of pension withdrawals will be based on your individual circumstances, tax legislation and regulation which are subject to change in the future.

What our clients say

The people we help are at the heart of what we do. Here are some of their testimonials.

I would highly recommend Darius and John. I’ve used a financial adviser previously and could never get in contact with them when I needed their help. Stratton Wealth Management have been excellent from the start. They are always available to talk, and they also don’t talk in financial jargon!

Dave Rigby -

A client since 2015

Having recently transferred my financial management to Stratton Wealth Management, I have been extremely impressed with the highly professional service I have received. I feel I have been fully involved in all decision making, and the company's highly skilled advisers have shown commitment and patience in any dealings I have had with them. I have also always found them to be easily accessible for any discussion I may require.

Denise Thornton -

A client since 2019

As a business owner and father of four children, finances are usually the last thing we think about. Stratton oversees and manages our finances, both in terms of advice for my business and our personal investments. It is comforting to know that our retirement, investment and life insurance planning has been taken care of. Darius and John are always so efficient in dealing with our affairs. As someone with no real understanding of the ins and outs, it has been fantastic to have experts giving us great advice and making sure our best interests are always the top priority.

Lee and Claire Parkinson -

Clients since 2016

Darius deals with my family’s finances and is a very trusted adviser. We meet a number of times a year, but I know I can call him any time if I have any questions. He is proactive, helpful and friendly!

Jonathan Dennis -

A client since 2019

I knew I needed to begin saving and planning for the future but didn’t know where to start. Stratton helped me to understand my finances and put together a savings plan that is affordable and works for me. I now have and an ISA and a pension, and whilst retirement is many years away, I have the peace of mind that I am saving for my future. I look forward to working with them for many years to come.

Martin Corrigan -

A client since 2016

I have been impressed with the advice and service provided by Stratton Wealth Management and have always found Darius to be approachable, dependable and highly professional in his approach. It is reassuring to be able to have such a high level of confidence and trust when it comes to financial advice.

Russell Jones -

A client since 2018

Many thanks indeed for your in depth report for my client Mrs H – it is most thorough and above all readable. This might sound particularly strange; however you may well gather that in my profession we see many such reports, and I often feel that if the adviser fills it with charts and graphs it evidences a level of research. In truth most of what is produced is readily obtainable from the internet.

I would like to thank you (and your organisation) for your prompt and professional attention to my requirements on behalf of my client. As a practice we shall definitely be putting Stratton Wealth Management on our “preferred supplier list".

Colin Dunstall, Donaldson Dunstall Solicitors -

A client since 2015